When Shape Meets Substance

Shape, substance, and the inherent dance: a sarcastic journey into the essence of stuff.
April 4, 2024 by
When Shape Meets Substance
Alessandro Liggieri

Embark on the weirdest journey of your life: Greek philosophy like you've never dared to imagine. Yeah, dared.

Buckle up: Plato and the gang like never before 

So, get comfy and prepare to leap back in time, but forget those dusty old tomes you'd expect to find in a library forsaken by God. Picture being invited to an exclusive party, where the guests are none other than the Greek philosophers. Yes, those guys, in their togas (hopefully wearing something underneath) and heads full of ideas that'll change the world.

"Ready to take the plunge? The substantial immanence according to the Greeks" – might sound like the title of a lecture that would bore you to dehydration, but I assure you, it'll be anything but dull. Why? Because we'll be envisioning Plato as that guy at the party who never stops talking about his "Forms of Ideas," trying to convince you that the chair you're sitting on isn't really a chair. And Aristotle? He's the pragmatic friend trying to bring him back down to Earth, insisting that if it looks like a chair and functions like a chair, then it's probably a chair.

On this journey, you'll discover that these ancient thinkers had ideas so revolutionary they might even make your favorite vlog look a tad less interesting. And the best part? We'll do it in your language, without all those complicated terms that give you a headache just pronouncing them.

So, are you ready to explore how Greek philosophy can explain why you feel lost in the cereal aisle or why you keep arguing with your bestie over which movie is the greatest of all time? Follow us on this adventure, where form meets substance in ways you'd never imagine, all seasoned with a dash of Moore-esque sarcasm. I promise, by the end of this journey, you'll look at Plato and Aristotle more like two old friends you'd want to grab coffee with, rather than two statues in a museum.

And now, ladies and gentlemen, let's dive into the heart of the party, where the lights dim, the music softens, and the Greek philosophers begin to reveal the universe's secrets, one aperitif at a time. But beware, we won't be delving into tedious academic disquisitions; rather, imagine being in a trendy bar with Plato, Aristotle, and a handful of other thinkers who, between one metaphysical cocktail and the next, passionately discuss form, substance, and, why not, the best strategy to win at foosball. 

Plato: the DJ of Forms of Ideas

Imagine Plato not as a philosopher with a long beard and wrinkled robes from spending too much time locked in a library, but as the coolest DJ at the philosophy party. Yes, Plato, with headphones on, ready to spin not vinyl, but Forms of Ideas. Here's Plato: the DJ of Forms of Ideas, making minds and souls dance to the transcendental rhythm of being.

"Folks, come closer to the console of knowledge!" shouts Plato, as his secret playlist shakes the foundations of the sensible world. But what's he playing? Not the usual hit of the moment, oh no. It's something you've never heard before: the pure form of everything, from the ethereal swing of an "Ideal Dog" to the unblemished melody of a "Perfect Chair."

As the dance floor fills, Plato takes you by the hand, guiding you on a journey through the world of Ideas, an exclusive club where entry is only granted to those willing to think beyond the tangible. "See that chair over there?" he asks, pointing to a dimly lit corner of the venue. "That's just the shadow, the faded imitation of the true Chair you can find here, in my playlist."

He explains how every object, every concept we know in the sensible world, is just a remix, a cover of its original form that he, and only he, can spin. And as you're there, dancing among the Ideas of Virtue, Justice, and Beauty, you begin to realize that maybe, just maybe, there's more to life than what your eyes can see.

But beware: Plato's not the type to let go easily. Every now and then, he throws one of those philosophical curveball questions, like "If you dance with the Idea of a Chair, are you really sitting?" And as you try to keep up with his reflections, you realize the real fun is in searching for the answers, not necessarily finding them.

At the end of the night, as the lights come on and the music fades, you find yourself thinking this party with DJ Plato might have been one of the best you've ever attended. Not only did you dance till dawn, but you also traveled to a world you didn't know existed, where Forms of Ideas rule supreme, and where a chair is never just a chair.

So, as Plato packs up his console and headphones, he leaves you with a thought: "Remember, my friend, the world of Ideas is always open. Just find the right track and let yourself go to the rhythm of existence." And as you leave the venue, with your head still full of transcendental melodies, you realize this is one of those nights you won't easily forget. Not only did you learn to see beyond appearances, but you also discovered the secret to always being at the center of the dance floor: dancing to the rhythm of Ideas.

Aristotle: the rebel with a cause... and form

After an unforgettable night at the club of Forms of Ideas with DJ Plato, you're ready for the sequel, and who better than Aristotle to turn up the volume? This is when Aristotle makes his entrance, not with DJ headphones but with the demeanor of a music critic who's listened to all the tracks, met all the DJs, and now is ready to tell you how things really are. Yes, because for Aristotle, substance takes form in ways not even Plato's best beat can match.

"Okay, my friend, playtime's over," says Aristotle, gently taking the drink from your hand and replacing it with a biology textbook. "You've danced all night with Ideas, but have you ever stopped to think about what makes the dance possible? Your feet, your muscles, the floor that supports you?"

And as you look at him, a bit puzzled, because honestly, who wants to think about biology after a night of philosophical debauchery, it starts to make sense. Aristotle isn't here to kill the party; he's here to add another layer, to take you from a purely abstract dimension to something more... tangible.

"Let's start with the basics," he continues, turning on the projector and showing you slides that seem to have been stolen from an advanced university physics course. "Everything you can see, touch, feel, has a form, yes, but it also has a substance. It's the substance that gives form its reality, its tangibility."

And then, with a smile that smells of challenge, Aristotle takes you outside the club. You find yourself in a park at dawn, with the grass still wet with dew under your feet. "Now, try to dance here," he urges you.

At first, you're hesitant, but then you let go, and as you dance, you start to feel. Really feel. The earth beneath your feet, the fresh air on your face, the rhythm of your heart beating in your chest. And you understand what Aristotle is trying to teach you: every dance, every movement, every musical note exists only through the substance that makes it real.

"See," says Aristotle, watching you dance with a pleased smile, "music, dance, life itself... Everything needs a substance to truly exist. Forms of Ideas are beautiful, but it's the substance and form together that create the symphony of existence."

As the sun rises, illuminating the park with its first rays of dawn, you feel grateful to Aristotle for overturning Plato's perspective. It's not that one vision replaces the other; rather, they complement each other. Plato's Forms of Ideas give you the melody, but it's Aristotle's substance that allows you to dance.

And as the philosophical music critic walks away, leaving you to reflect on your new discoveries, you realize you've just experienced another unforgettable night, one that taught you not only to think but to truly feel the music of the universe. Yes, Aristotle rebelled, but he did so to bring you to a deeper, more tangible understanding of the world. And for that, you can never be grateful enough.

The moral of the story: ancient Greeks as influencers  

After spending a night among the clouds with Plato, dancing on the unreachable peaks of Forms of Ideas, and then finding yourself barefoot in the park at dawn, learning from Aristotle how everything around you sings its existence through substance, here you are. Yes, right here, in the middle of the path between the sky of ideas and the earth of reality, trying to square the circle, or perhaps to make form and substance dance together.

"So what? Greek philosophy in our daily lives" might seem too pompous a title to conclude this adventure, but stay with me for a moment. Because, you see, after a evening spent with two of the greatest minds in human thought, you find yourself wondering: now what? What do I do with all this philosophy while I try not to spill coffee on myself, rushing to the office?

The truth, my friend, is that Plato and Aristotle were not just two old men with a passion for togas and endless dialogues. They were masters in the noble art of making us see beyond the obvious, of pushing us to question not just what a chair is, but what makes our life worth living.

From Plato, we learn to look beyond appearances, to search for that divine spark that resides in everything, even in the most mundane objects or everyday events. It's that spark that lights up moments of doubt, that pushes us to seek a deeper meaning behind the veil of routine.

From Aristotle, on the other hand, we receive the gift of concreteness, of grounding ourselves and recognizing the value of experience, of empirical knowledge. He teaches us that, yes, it's important to dream and aspire to the ideal, but it's also crucial to act, to do, to be present in the world in an active and conscious way.

So, how do we apply these lessons in the frenzy of modern life? Simple: by remembering that every day offers us the opportunity to seek beauty in Plato's Forms of Ideas and to act concretely in Aristotle's world. Whether it's choosing words carefully to comfort a friend, appreciating art in an unexpected mural on the way to work, or finding the courage to pursue a dream, Greek philosophy equips us with the tools to live a richer, more meaningful life.

In conclusion, after spending the night discussing with Plato and Aristotle, you find yourself at the crossroads between idea and matter, between dream and action. And here, in the twilight between thought and reality, you realize that true wisdom lies in dancing along that line, learning to move to the rhythm that unites heaven and earth.

So, the next time you feel lost amid the challenges of everyday life, remember this night spent in the company of the giants of philosophy. Let their voices guide you, not as distant echoes of a forgotten past, but as travel companions on your personal journey to discover what really matters. Plato and Aristotle are not just names on a book page; they are a lighthouse and compass to navigate the vast ocean of existence. And now, armed with this knowledge, you're ready to shine your light in the world, one step, one thought, one dance at a time.

Why I recommend it

I recommend delving into Greek philosophy because... it'll help you understand that every new beginning has ancient roots, even your daily chaos. 

Why I don't recommend it

I don't recommend diving into Greek philosophy because... you might end up questioning the reality of everything, including your morning coffee. 

I give you advice, then it's up to you...

  Looking to add a philosophical touch to your daily scroll? Follow me and brighten your day with a bit of Greek wisdom. 

Subscribe To The Blog

When Shape Meets Substance
Alessandro Liggieri April 4, 2024
Share this post
Archive